Loan vs Invest Decision Helper
Compare paying off debt vs investing with after-tax analysis. Enter values for instant results with step-by-step formulas.
Formula
Net Benefit = After-Tax Investment Gain - After-Tax Loan Interest; Spread = Investment Return - Effective Loan Rate
Worked Examples
Example 1: Student Loan vs S&P 500
Problem: $50K student loan at 5%, 10-year term. Have $50K inheritance. Expected market return 8%. 24% tax bracket. Interest is tax-deductible.
Solution: Loan Analysis:\nMonthly payment: $530\nTotal interest: $13,639\nAfter-tax interest (24% bracket): $10,366\nEffective rate: 5% ร (1-0.24) = 3.8%\n\nInvest Analysis:\n$50K at 8% for 10 years: $107,946\nGain: $57,946\nCapital gains tax (15%): $8,692\nAfter-tax gain: $49,254\n\nComparison:\nInvesting net: $49,254 - $10,366 = $38,888 ahead\n\nSpread: 8% - 3.8% = 4.2% (strong)\n\nRecommendation: Invest. Strong positive spread, and deductibility reduces effective loan cost significantly.
Result: Invest | $38,888 net benefit | 4.2% spread | Deductibility helps
Example 2: Car Loan - High Rate
Problem: $30K car loan at 9%, 5-year term. Have $30K savings. Expected return 7%. Not tax-deductible. 22% bracket.
Solution: Loan Analysis:\nMonthly payment: $623\nTotal interest: $7,376\nNo tax benefit (consumer debt)\nEffective rate: 9%\n\nInvest Analysis:\n$30K at 7% for 5 years: $42,077\nGain: $12,077\nAfter-tax gain: $10,265\n\nComparison:\nInvesting net: $10,265 - $7,376 = $2,889 ahead\n\nBUT spread is only 7% - 9% = -2%!\n\nMathematically, investing still ahead due to compounding,\nbut the negative spread means risk is not rewarded.\n\nRecommendation: Pay off loan.\nGuaranteed 9% return beats uncertain 7%.
Result: Pay Off Loan | Guaranteed 9% > uncertain 7% | Negative spread
Example 3: Mortgage - Low Rate
Problem: $300K mortgage at 3.5%, 30 years. Have $100K to either invest or pay toward principal. Expected return 8%. 32% tax bracket. Mortgage interest deductible.
Solution: Mortgage effective rate:\n3.5% ร (1-0.32) = 2.38%\n\nInvest $100K at 8% for 10 years:\n$215,892 | After-tax gain: $98,508\n\nPay down mortgage:\nSaves ~$50K interest over 10 years (complex calc)\nGuaranteed 2.38% effective return\n\nSpread: 8% - 2.38% = 5.62% (very strong)\n\nOver 10 years, investing likely adds ~$48K more wealth than paydown.\n\nRecommendation: Invest, especially in tax-advantaged accounts.\nMortgage is cheapest debt most people have.\nMaintain liquidity for opportunities.
Result: Invest | 5.62% spread | Mortgage is cheap debt | Maximize tax-advantaged accounts first
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I pay off debt or invest?
Compare after-tax interest rate on debt vs expected after-tax investment return. If investment return > debt rate + 1-2% risk premium, investing may be better mathematically. But consider: debt payoff is guaranteed return; investments are uncertain. Risk tolerance matters.
How does tax deductibility affect the decision?
Deductible interest (mortgage, student loans, business) reduces effective rate. 6% mortgage at 24% tax bracket = 4.56% effective rate. Compare this lower effective rate to after-tax investment returns. Deductibility favors investing over payoff.
Does loan term affect the decision?
Longer terms mean more interest paid but also more time for investments to compound. Short-term loans favor payoff (less time for investment gains). Long-term low-rate loans favor investing (more compounding time).
What inputs do I need to use Loan vs Invest Decision Helper accurately?
Each field is labelled with the required unit (metric or imperial). Gather your source values before starting โ for example, a weight measurement in kilograms, a distance in metres, or a dollar amount โ and enter them exactly as measured. The formula section on this page lists every variable and explains what each represents.
How accurate are the results from Loan vs Invest Decision Helper?
All calculations use established mathematical formulas and are performed with high-precision arithmetic. Results are accurate to the precision shown. For critical decisions in finance, medicine, or engineering, always verify results with a qualified professional.
Does Loan vs Invest Decision Helper work offline?
Once the page is loaded, the calculation logic runs entirely in your browser. If you have already opened the page, most calculators will continue to work even if your internet connection is lost, since no server requests are needed for computation.